Fellow spiritual knowledge seekers:
Pranam.
Of late, this blog has been receiving mails from persons claiming to represent Swami Paramarthananda demanding that this blog remove all discourses of Swamiji presently placed here. Placing this issue before you for your valued opinions, the links to Swamiji’s discourses in this blog will temporarily be disabled.
In this day and age of internet, I wonder how this blog can be accused of copyright violation. As you all know, discourses by Swamiji (and, others) are available in dozens of websites, blogs and forums spread across the Net. I had (and, continue to have) the great fortune to listen to Swamiji’s many discourses downloaded from the Net since the past three years. As the collection of discourses by Swamiji and other jnanis grew, I thought of sharing this wealth with other spiritual seekers by placing these in easy categories in a blog. That’s all.
A great jnani as he is, Swami Paramarthananda repeatedly says in his upanyasas that as a Guru , he feels it is his duty to teach and share his spiritual knowledge and that he enjoys it. And, for spiritual seekers spread across the globe who do not have any resources other than the Net to access these treasures, is it Inappropriate to share these and help each other in their spiritual pursuits?
Please let us know your thoughts. The decision to continue to keep Swamiji’s discourses in this blog or not will be yours.
Hari Ohm.
Sumukam’s Blog
Like this:
Filed under: Uncategorized
Very Good process. If you can send me the discourses of Swamiji as it is regularly at my email i.d. shyamalaaniyan@yahoo.com
Hi,
You are doing a great service by disseminating Swamiji’s classes far and wide on the internet. A simple solution would be to talk to Swamiji and understand his views on this matter. I’m quite certain that he would fully support your endeavour to put his talks on your site.
Thank you very much for your service.
- Vinod.
Pujiya Swami Ji Maharaj: My humble pranam. It is unbelievable to know that someone can object to such a noble work that you have done with tremendous amount of hard work. It is of immense help to millions of devotees of Hindu religion all over the world. Please do let us know if
we could make a humble offering to maintain and further improve this
website.
Dear Friend,
I am really moved and thankful for your help and support;
All these swamiji’s are there to claim the copyright, but still there are temples where there is no oil/dress for teh deity’s still exists;
Some of my friends as a group is sending oil and supports many priests within Tamil Nadu;
Please make sure that the person who is asking you to shutdown is representing swamiji; There are so many others who doesn’t want the good things to happen that is Kaliyuga we cannot blame anyone;
Requesting you not to shutdown, instead whoever downloads can even provide an amount to swamiji online to make him or his subordinate happy;
Also a small request to all the Swamiji’s – Please help the poor people who are guided wrong and converted to other religions and they couldn’t come back and suffering; Any GuruPeet should be a place where valuable human beings should evolve and not money/material minded advocates/accounts should evolve;
Once again THANK U SO MUCH for your effort;
Regards,
dAsan
Mani – Chennai – Ashok Nagar
Indeed it is a great service to humanity as such. wonderful collection. At this old age, we can no go & attend lectures. By getting them in the web, we are able to learn so much & use our time in noble pursuit.
Kindly keep uploading good divine lectures. If money alone is the concern, the noble beings whose lectures, you are uploading would not be giving such wonderful lectures at all.
There is no harm at all in using these lectures/discourses.
Hari Om
Sumukamji you had done an excellent job. Sruthi & Smirithi has to be kearnt from Guru. But it is not possible now days. Hence many spiritual seekers are outside chennai & India. This site will be helpful. So kindly dont remove the discourse please. Especially spiritual seekers in Saudi Arabia & Gulf cant take CDs there, hence this blog will be useful.
One request to the seekers. kindly donate money for the discourse you download.
Hariom
Krishnakumar
no words to thanks for your service ,what a hard work you done for do this spritual knowledge collection , i search your contact mail to appriciate your work but i cant get so i wish you on this form , please never close this site off line because last week swami guruparanda sites is gone off line , how i got sad you know no words after i seach his details in google i got your site when i see your collection of spritual work no words to tell i am soo happy , thanks you much thanks thanks thanks thanks what can i do for explain my happiness
You must continue please. Hindu thoughts must spread. Based on this, people will always pay voluntarily at whatever time they deem fit. There is no need to make money through “rights”.
KINDLY CONTINUE THE SERVICE YOU ARE DOING
with best wishes,
S.P.KRISHNAMOORTHY
Ram Ram
Our Sanadana Dharma should spread the culture of sravana (listening) and smarana. For that we require inspiring discourses/lectures. In the name of “rights” restricting spiritual knowledge to select few or those who pay does not help our religion. You may continue to serve the way you do now helping those who are physically and geographically separted but heart of heart want to be united in seeking higher knowledge
Hari OM
Love your service; My appreciations; For months, on daily basis, I was listening to Swamiji via different source I downloaded: I was blessed- but suddenly my PC crashed; foolish enough not to have safeguarded it by a separate storage, I was sad and heartstricken; I just chanced to go to your blog: I am happy to listen to Swamiji again;
Previous talks I had were Swamiji’s Coimbatore recordings-much more detailed -but your blog fulfills our hearts’ yearning to hear the voice of Swamiji with much more vigor, renowned venerance from all of us– but I shudder at the very thought.”I lost it; I regained it; “Will I ever lose it?”.
Just as Kambar said “KANN IZANDHAN PETRU EZANDAL ENA?’; I strongly endorse ipinions of all of us to continue this blog, support all links to Swamiji’s Discourses as they are immensely valuable, utterly
“priceless” gifts to humanity – and so your efforts are equally priceless.
I have seen other websites collect donations to provide the talks; some have already disappeared from the scene after the donations. We dont want to lose you.
I suggest each one of us, individually pay Guru Dakshina to Swamiji–however small it be–with purity in heart, utter humility, 100% sincerity spirit of reverence to our Swamiji by each of us whenever we like, individually to the Swamiji.
A periodic dakshina as I reiterate, could be as small as your heart and wallet permit, will be appropriate. Swamiji is God’s boon to understand our scriptures, our own Veda, and thus helps us identify our own SELF, to re-discover our inner self with all its strengths;
Salutations to Swami Paramarthananda
With best regards
Mani
Its a Great Service You Are Doing For The Hinduism And Tamil, at any cost please don’t let the blog die, its our responsibility to let our culture and religion reach our next generation! every one here not even aware of such great discourses exists, even if we know, now a days it’s really impossible to get these type of Discourses/speeches in tape or cd form , it will be not be affordable for everyone to buy this, Handle the copy right problems carefully and don’t let this blog die at any cost, please! Thanks !
I totally agrre…
please don’t let the blog die,
I totally agree with you…
Regards,
Thiru
Please continue the good work and dont remove the blog, unless you have got some specific mandate from
swamiji to do so.However listeners can send some guru dakshina to swamiji, because no knowledge should be taken for free and the tradaition which Sri Swamiji follows does not insist on any dakshina, all contributions are totally voluntary.
I have been listening to Pujya Swamijis talks for over 5 years in the site http://www.vedantavidyartisangha.org. Here however only last 4 classes are avl….and I have also seen a note about the copy right..
Whether it is appropriate to have a copy right for such a teaching where any can can attend and also record in their recorders.
I am also attending classes at Bangalore of Swami Sadatmanandaji for over 7 years now…..who is from the same tradation and his talks are avl for all with http://www.arshavidyakendratrust.org….even Swami Dayanandaji talks are avl for free in the web site.
This site is a boon ….for any time old talks can be referred to…..and I suggest this may be taken up with Swami Paramarthanandaji directly for his views.
regards…V.Sunderam@in.com
my pranams to swamiji. his lectures are very valuable
treasure and thanks to Sumukam for sharing this treasure
with all those who are around the globe, those elders
and those from other cities, who are unable to attend
swamiji’s classes. The following points may kindly
be considered by one and all:
1) I have seen many students record swamiji’s lectures
and even share them with other students. This shows
that swamiji himself may not object the spreading of
the vedic knowledge he is propagating.
2) Swamiji’s lectures are professionally recorded with
all care & pains, by Sastraprakasika Trust, which sells
Audio Tapes & CDs at very reasonable price. Therefore
if Sumukam has carried out the uploads from Tapes/CDs
purchased from Sastraprakasika, then necessary permission
need to be taken from them. If the uploads are done
from students’ personal recordings, then Sumukam can
make a strong appeal to downloaders to send GuruDakshina
to Swamiji.
3) Sumukam is rendering a great service in the field
of spirituality and their uploads of swamiji’s lectures
should be continued. For this purpose Sumukam can set
up a group of persons to help this out.
Hari Om.
My sashtanga pranams to the Holy feet of H.H Swamiji for providing such a wealth of our shastras and scriptures.For people like me,who are not fortunate enough to hear to H.H.Swamiji’s discourses by attending to satsanga, this blog is very useful.Please do not remove the lectures.
Piease continue the service Thousands will benefit
Namaskaram
It is a very good service to share the lectures given by Swamijis…Please continue this as Karma yoga. May Bhagavan bless all Sreyas and peace in your life
Radhakrishnan.V
Pranams.
I certainly doubt these people who claim to represent Swamiji. I cannot believe that a great soul like him who has chosen to share his knowledge with other seekers would prevent the sharing of his discourses.
As you point out, his discourses are available elsewhere. I would support you in ignoring these people and continue to provide Swamiji’s discourses.
Deepa
I am Swami Paramarthananda’s student for the last over 2 decades.I was made aware of this website recently and was thrilled to see SP’s talks made so easily available to the public. I live in the United States and do not visit India frequently. Websites like this one are quite often, the only means to access my Guru’s classes. Although I am personally in favor of the website, I would request the moderators of this website to present the question of propriety of its continuation to Pujya Swamiji himself and take appropriate action based on Swamiji’s advice.
SAIRAM. Namasthe. Your blog is NOT COMMERCIAL to derive any benefit for you. It is an appreciable free social service. Yet, it will be better to have a ‘No Objection’ from the copyright holders. This will avoid complications. This is my opinion.
hi. when mormans keep knocking on my door steps as they always do to spread the word of Jesus in Sydney; The only resource that has helped me to defend Sanathana Dharma are the talks by Swamiji. I’m sure Swamiji will have no objection to the content on the blog if he knew the real intention of this blog which is to spread the ultimate knowledge to people around the globe who are not as fortunate as the locals to attend his lectures. Keep up the good work.
Chetan.
Dear sir,
Namaskarams. You are doing a great service to one and all through this blog of yours. Please keep the contents in the blog as there is no evidence that the swamiji is objecting to this.
This service should not be stopped. It is not easy to build one like this. For seekers like us nothing better can be offered than this. This is a treasure. Please dont stop
we would love to watch the video discourse on new year 2012 by
swami paramarthanandaji. kindly help us.Hari om.
pl see http://www.vedantavidyarthisangha.org/
If Swamiji’s or the copyright owner’s permission has not been expressly obtained, it is not right to publish them. There can’t be a second opinion, ethical or legal, on this.
Hari OM!
Sir , with all my humility I beg to place my thoughts. All do not know sri sri paramarthanand ji.his super discourses are vey much enlightening even the village iillitrate people.His lectures are available in casette/disc and the person who complied all this have incurred expences. to TAKE ANY THING IN THIS WORLD EVEN AIR WITHOUT DOING /CONTRIBUTING IS A SIN AND THE KNOWLEDGE SO ACRRUED WILL BE LOST BY HIM AT THE APPROPRIATE TIME.
SECONDLY, if THE HOLY MAN PERMITS ANY ONE CAN POST HIS TEACHINGS INTHE NET AND THE USERS CAN AVAIL IT .HOWEVER THEY MUST CONTRIBUTE THEIR MIGHT AT LEAST ONE RUPEE TO NOT EXPENCES BUT A A TOKEN
S.GOPALASWAMY
This is Kaliyug. So there is no time for Tapas, yagnam or darshan(which means standing for hours in the queue); God understands all these and He comes to our dwelling places and gives us knowledge and teaches us how to uplift ourselves through means like internet. That much time we spend in listening to all these discourses offered is quality time that creates positive vibrations and makes this world a better place. So let us pray “Long Live Sumukam Blog”.
you are doing a great service to ardent seekers .May the lord remove all such obstacles. please don’t stop your contributions.
Funny, I’m not sure What will you tell about ppl who demand “thank you” to download the stuff they uploaded but in first place they didn’t create it?
Swamiji is a great guru. His teachings are well-codified and well thought-out. For any person desirous of gaining vedantic knowledge, his discourses are a great boon. – Rajan Kallingal
Please do call and speak with Swamiji directly. All the recordings posted on this site are available with Sastraprakashika. You can get access to complete catalogue at http://www.vedantavidhyarthisangha.org.
Hari OM
I wonder if Sankara in the eighth century would have made this a business instead of spreading the truth. When knowledge is to be imparted to the nook and corner of the world such copy-right control on these spiritual area is to be frowned. I am sure Swami Paramartha Nanda would not stoop to these low levels of controlling the spread of rare spiritual activities for money unless he is controlled by the self appointed managers of the institution. Such control only restricts the activities and hence the growth.
namaste.
blessed soul,
This some times happens….I am a person trying to spread sanathana dharma messages to seekers through CD’s etc….I have also faced similar situation…..even if our motto is good..always there would be opposition…..this is the nature of the world…Keep doing your noble work..my salutations to you Sir…
God Bless you for your noble deeds
Manoj
Ram Ram
It is but proper that U take permission from Swamiji before you continue the good work.Pl meet him personally and explain that you are doing it as a service.
Ram Ram
K Sundararaman
Pranams!
Continue the great job unless you receive any direct correspondence from Him. We are blessed with your site.
Regards,
Nagarajan Iyer
Radhe Krishna
Spiritualism flows down traditionally, from time immemorial and all the Gurus are very happy to spread it all over this Universe without claiming any right.
Namaskarams. I have greatly benefitted from Swamiji’s lectures. And he has mentioned in one of the lectures that he has no objection in wide public getting the benefit. So u shdnt remove the blog.
If someone still persists, pl ask them to send it in writing and we will take it to Swamiji for his approval.
I live outside India but I dont mind coming to Chennai to meet Swamiji (and this will give me an opportunity to meet him) and resolve this issue. So, pl dont remove the lectures. Its a great service to humanity.
Namaskarams – Ayappan Ramamurthy
if there is no evidence for the claims that the requests came from the swamiji himself, someone might be trying to deceive you for fun or some other motive. Maybe it is just another rival of your blog or even that of sanathana dharma itself. I hope atleast devotion stays itself clear out of copyright, business and all other selfish acts.
Pranams to the holy feet of all the blessed ones using this blog !
Please keep the contents shared as long as it exists in other blogs and places in the internet or as long as SWAMIJI HIMSELF sends you a personal request !
We can never be sure about the people who claim to be HIS devotees and their intents !
Please continue this seva !
With Prayers,
+Naadhan
PL continue to have the same on the net. I hope that the objections will beonly from a few who assusme that they are representing Sri Swamiji and not from the Swamiji himself who wishes to preach good things.
Please continue sharing
The rishis of yore had never copy-righted
We pay obeisance to our Great Gurus who make us understand the Truth
We are blessed to offer Guru kaanikkai with reverance
Please check this fb group.
https://www.facebook.com/groups/SPFollowers/
Please continue with this yeomen service. Donot stop it. Swami Paramarthananda’s talks have given clarity to so many people including me. I will post your concer in the SP ji’s Facebook group. It has more than 300 members. I will get you support.
Also please check with the SP ji directly before removing the content. He is very accessible.
I am having a mixed opinion.
First uploading a discourse without the consents of the owner of the copy right of course is not right but same time I will never come across Swamis discourse if it was not in your blog.
I think you should request to swami directly to get his opinion of spreading his teaching globally. I am in the opinion that this should spread globally as his teachings are very crisp, clear to the point and easy to understood by any ordinary spiritual seeker.
My prayer is with you for all your Good work
Pranams,
Giving accessibility to truth and sharing knowledge without hindrance is the greatest service anyone can do in one’s life. I do not understand the objections from whichever quarters it may be dissuading the continuance of this blog. Yes, any misuse has to be dealt with. But it is the misuser who is going to reap the “paapa” of the karma. Why should anyone else be worried?
namaskarams
please continue the seva you are doing.
best wishes
balaji
My pranams to all. yes you should continue to keep swamiji’s speeaches in this blog. In olden days, Siddhi & finding the truth is kept as secret /otherwise they don’t know how to express. But now a days, as Lord Krishna’s words, God himself, come to Buloogam, to teach or preach the truth. As his words, like sri Paramarthanandha swami, sri Nochur venkatramanji has come to preach upanyasams to us and to make us to understand the truth. We can’t purchase the God and his blessings for us except his photos which we imagined. so one who involved in the spiritual line, they neednot be money minded.
If it is so, they are not involved themselves in aanmegam. In no classes, the above said swamijis are not prevent us to record their voices. If so why should we ask some sites to remove the upanyasams given by above swamijis. It is appropriate to share these and help each other in their spiritual ways.
I can specify another site to download their upanyasams. But i get fear that site may be troubled by the Good hearted people.
So, we shall help others to learn and turn to aanmegam or spiritual seekers. by adeyen sekar.
OM
Understanding SRUTI and SMRITI needs to be backed up by SampradAya teaching.SampradAya teaching involves clarity in the area of fine prints of sAstra.One cannot conclude or say that he/she knows everything and the effort to know is a waste!
A human mind settles for accepting what is said but capable of raising enough doubts in time.
For a teacher who is a sAstra vid and a smpradAya vid there should be only support and no impediments caused in his pursuit.
Any alternative action may facilitate individuals all over the GLOBE to access.
Swami Sarvabhutananda
I feel it is a great service to all serious students across the globe. I feel sharing good things with others is no crime.